Liz Phair
Whip-Smart
»
![]()
Liz Phair
Whip-Smart
Matador, 1994
RiYL: Aimee Mann, The Jesus And Mary Chain, Pavement's Brighten The Corners |
In fairness, Guyville is the kind of record that's really hard to follow up. Whip-Smart, to Phair's credit, is not an attempt to re-create the spontaneity or raw effect of her first record. But it is also not a huge leap forward.
Whip-Smart has a slicker sound, but still reflects Phair's basic instrumental ambitions. With cohorts Brad Wood and Casey Rice, she pounds out insistently melodic and lyrically inventive songs throughout the album.
On rhythmic songs like "X-Ray Man" and "Jealousy," Phair displays a seductive swagger, indulging in some dark, Rolling Stones-meet-Suzanne Vega rock energy. "Shane" and "Nashville" exemplify another end of Phair's spectrum, a detached narrator musing in a tired, husky voice (the last 90 seconds of the former has Phair's repetition of "You gotta have fear in your heart" steadily being replaced by a TV drone).
Phair's lyrics take a broader turn on Whip-Smart, directing specific scenes in "Dogs Of L.A." ("You were beaming as I focused in / and I panned along / and I raced you to the top / kicking snakes up from dusty rocks / young Abe Vigoda plays Frankenstein") and throwing out witty advice in "Whip-Smart" (I'm gonna tell my son to keep his money in his mattress / and his watch on any hand between his thighs").
Sure, Whip-Smart still stands in the shadow of Guyville, but it is definitely worthy of further inspection on its own merits. It proves Liz Phair's consistency and establishes her more firmly within the rock pantheon.
TROY CARPENTER | Troy Carpenter founded NATN from a Chicago apartment during the ambitious winter of 1998 with co-conspirators Ben French and Jonathan Cohen. After a five-year stint in New York, he and wife Lourdes have recently relocated to Indianapolis, where he spends days listening to music and nights in the kitchen at Elements restaurant. Musical heroes: Jimi Hendrix, Bob Marley, Super Furry Animals. What else makes life worth living: Sushi, Phucty, runs in the park, and the Atlanta Braves.
