Robert Pollard
Not In My Airforce
»
![]()
Robert Pollard
Not In My Airforce
Matador, 1996
RiYL: Sebadoh, The Soft Boys, Wire |
At the time of its release (Carnival Boy, a solo album by former GBV cohort Tobin Sprout, streeted on the same day), most decried the record's credits by saying there wasn't much difference between a Pollard "solo" album which featured contributions from his GBV bandmates and a bona fide GBV outing. In retrospect, however, the fallacy of this thought pattern has become evident.
Guided By Voices, at least since its coming-out era in the early '90s (Propeller-Bee Thousand), has been on a steady evolutionary track. While not decreasing the group's astounding level of productivity, GBV has consistently cleaned up its production while filling out songs' construction and generally heading toward full-on rock glory a la this year's barnburner Isolation Drills.
Meanwhile, Pollard himself has engaged in a number of various side projects (since his third solo record, Kid Marine, most of these have come under the guise of the Fading Captain Series) that really don't follow any given track besides the whim of their creators.
Not In My Airforce, for one, was having none of the clarity or coherence of all subsequent GBV recordings. Sure, there are full fledged tunes on here, like opener "Maggie Turns To Flies," the evocative mid-tempo "Girl Named Captain" and the addictive anthem "Psychic Pilot Clocks Out." But a good portion of the record is what most self-respecting music listeners would call "toss-aways" ("One Clear Minute," "John Strange School," "Prom Is Coming") and some that seem to have been picked for inclusion on not much more merit than their titles ("Double Standards Inc.," "King Of Arthur Avenue").
Still, in that inimitable way of Pollard's, Not In My Airforce rises above its sludgy production and questionable song selection to actually be a worthy (dare i say 'essential'? probably not.) addition to the extensive Pollard catalog. It's an interesting, if not quite bold, statement that he makes to differentiate between a solo album and a GBV album, and Not In My Airforce is the blueprint that allows this distinction. There are moments on here that approach his best, like the closing couplet to "Girl Named Captain" (Raise the dead / a girl named Captain said / I'm not in your dream, get out of mine"). GBV still plays many of these songs live, and no Pollard collection is complete without "Psychic Pilot." There you go.
TROY CARPENTER | Troy Carpenter founded NATN from a Chicago apartment during the ambitious winter of 1998 with co-conspirators Ben French and Jonathan Cohen. After a five-year stint in New York, he and wife Lourdes have recently relocated to Indianapolis, where he spends days listening to music and nights in the kitchen at Elements restaurant. Musical heroes: Jimi Hendrix, Bob Marley, Super Furry Animals. What else makes life worth living: Sushi, Phucty, runs in the park, and the Atlanta Braves.
