Robert Pollard
From A Compound Eye
»
![]()
Robert Pollard
From A Compound Eye
Merge, 2006
RiYL: Wire, Ween, Showbiz Opera Walrus |
Captain Bob this time around is in full-speed-ahead mode, having done away with the GBV moniker but not really doing anything drastic with his modus operandi. Recorded with longtime co-conspirator Todd Tobias as well as Chris Sheehan and Scott Bennett, From A Compound Eye does have an air of supreme confidence, which helps elevate seemingly tossed-off song ideas into impressive workouts. But that’s not anything different from what Pollard has been doing throughout his career. Anthemic rockers are not in short supply here, ranging from the swaggering “Kick Me And Cancel” to the lascivious “I’m A Widow.” But he also shows his soft side for bouncy bubblegum like “Dancing Girls And Dancing Men” and spirited melancholy like the R.E.M.-invoking “Blessed In An Open Head.”
A song like “The Right Thing” is a great example of what sets Pollard apart from his contemporaries in terms of striking a balance between gross prolificity and sheer brilliance. The track starts off in demo form, and it’s in shambles. Pollard plaintively whines over a tinny acoustic guitar, and his voice reaches truly hilarious levels of twee-ness, as he squeaks out “I am high / you cry.” Another ridiculous fragment, right? But then in comes the rock, as the band breaks into the full-electric version of the song, and Pollard amazingly turns it around. Now you’re singing along to his asinine chorus: “I am high / you cry / and I die” and then as they beat the riff into sweet oblivion, what is that we hear? A mouth organ solo? Sure, why not.
And there’s dozens more where those come from. 26 songs in total. Are they all good? I couldn’t tell you. The more you listen to “Cock Of The Rainbow” or “50 Year Old Baby,” the more you might convince yourself these are great tunes, and maybe even impeccable work by the songsmith. But then you remember his 20-year career and even this 26-song monolith starts to seem minute.
Of course it isn’t. Pollard is still going strong, just as we suspected, and breaking up Guided By Voices, the band/band name that made him famous isn’t going to make a lick of difference to his ability to keep churning out quality rock and roll for the next 20 years.
TROY CARPENTER | Troy Carpenter founded NATN from a Chicago apartment during the ambitious winter of 1998 with co-conspirators Ben French and Jonathan Cohen. After a five-year stint in New York, he and wife Lourdes have recently relocated to Indianapolis, where he spends days listening to music and nights in the kitchen at Elements restaurant. Musical heroes: Jimi Hendrix, Bob Marley, Super Furry Animals. What else makes life worth living: Sushi, Phucty, runs in the park, and the Atlanta Braves.
