Back to Nude as the News
nude as the 90s

 

Miseducation

The Miseducation Of..
Lauryn Hill
Ruffhouse, 1998

Reviewed by Jeff Vrabel


It's tough to write a review about The Miseducation Of Lauryn Hill with an existing musical vocabulary. One finds himself trying to fit the words hip-hop, reggae, blues, jazz and R&B into one sentence with the words writer, producer, vocalist and hip-hop artist. It's ultimately much easier to use just one word: soul.

Lauryn Hill first gained recognition as the frontwoman for the Fugees, whose second album The Score - itself a landmark fusion of hip-hop, reggae, rhythm and blues - hijacked pop radio with its covers of "Killing Me Softly" and "No Woman, No Cry" and went on to sell 17 million copies. But it was 1998's Miseducation, a nearly unclassifiable masterpiece of hip-hop, reggae ... well, you get the idea ... that unleashed on Hill an avalanche of worldwide accolade. In the span of one whole album, the 23-year-old was being mentioned in the same articles as Aretha, Marvin and Stevie.

These are brutal standards to live up to, but Miseducation succeeds almost across the board. Hill pulls this off by obliterating almost all existing boundaries in hip-hop (especially those set up to women), bouncing from smooth soul to defiant rap in the same song. The best example of this is the album's flagship single, "Doo Wop (That Thing)", which finds her harmonizing on 1950s "woo-hoo" choruses while spitting distinctly '90s verses that admonish both easy women ("It's silly when girls sell their soul because it's in") and wannabe players ("Cristal by the case men, still in they mother's basement") with equal street knowledge.

More tellingly, Hill fires a few salvos at Fugees' bandmate Wyclef Jean, who has publicly claimed responsibility for the group's success. Both the album's opener "Lost Ones," which rolls nicely over a hip-hop/reggae jump beat, and "Superstar" appear to document Lauryn's well-publicized struggles with Clef (although not by name): "Everything you did has already been done/I know all the tricks from Bricks to Kingston."

It's that kind of independence that drives the listener through the record, especially coming in a period when R&B and hip-hop is populated almost entirely by boring dollar-bill-y'all lyricism and assertions of female power that are questionable at best (please see Carey, Mariah).

Perhaps the album's defining moment is "To Zion," a gospel missive to Hill's first son. Chronicling her decision to have a child against the advice of friends (and, more likely, business associates), Hill's lyrics and voice remain defiantly proud throughout: "How beautiful if nothing more / Than to wait at Zion's door / I've never been in love like this before." If that song doesn't have soul, someone needs to modify the definition.

Similarly, Miseducation, even after the gushing critical accolades, the wall of comparisons and a year of consideration, still remains true, ultimately, to Lauryn herself. More than re-introducing a talent of such wide-ranging ability, it is a record that helped redefine soul for the 1990s, a period in bad need of it.


 

"Brash and humble at the same time, the largely auto- biographical work addresses topics ranging from materialism to racism to sexism, without resorting to pontification."

Mats Andersson
- Lauryn Hill Fan Site


Related Reviews

Fugees - The Score

Related Links
Lauryn Hill Homepage

 

             back | the list | back to natn | next