Unplugged In New York
Nirvana
DGC, 1994
Reviewed by
Patrick Kastner
Nirvana's Unplugged In New York is a wonderful record, a brief moment
of calm among almost constant tumult. Recorded just five months before Cobain took his own
life, it was an awful time for the band. Cobain was hopelessly addicted to heroin. His
frequent mood swings and depression left his bandmates constantly wondering what would
happen next.
But for that one December night in New York City, he was happy. They were happy. You can
hear it in his voice, in their playing, in the way he reverently rolled out some of his
favorite songs to cover, in the joy they found within their own songs that night.
With many of the Unplugged's songs ubiquitous on the radio in the years after
Cobain's death, it's hard to remember what a shock it was to see Nirvana on MTV's show
that had up to that point been the domain of more sedate performers. (Remember, probably
the two most famous shows prior to this were 10,000 Maniacs and an aging Eric Clapton, not
exactly barn-burners.)
But Cobain didn't want to be perceived as limited to the world of slash-and-burn grunge.
He had publicly expressed wishes to sound more like R.E.M. So this was his chance, and he
had a plan. Nirvana would only play its most tuneful songs on the program, placing them
side-by-side with great covers that few remembered. The result was the exact
transformation Cobain sought.
Anyone who had missed the band's brilliance on their last two albums couldn't possibly
deny their greatness now. Unfortunately, he wasn't around long enough to follow up on this
removal of stereotype. But the generation inspired by Cobain took note of his message:
Mere angst does not a great artist make. Nirvana's songs are classics even when taken out
of their original context.
Stripped of electricity, Cobain's themes shone through his music all the more brilliantly.
"About A Girl"'s debt to the Beatles was clear as day. "Dumb" and
"All Apologies" were rendered in an even greater beauty. "Pennyroyal
Tea" was sublime. Three songs with the Meat Puppets belied Cobain's playfulness. (And
once again, his genius. Who else could have listened to Meat Puppets II and known
just how great those songs were?)
But once again, Cobain saved his best for last. A cover of Leadbelly's "In The
Pines," titled "Where Did You Sleep Tonight?" here, was the show's
indisputable highlight. With a dread sense of foreboding, Cobain turned the tale of love
and betrayal into an epiphany. Building, repeating musically and lyrically until the
cathartic last verse was delivered with Cobain's trademark blood-curdling howl, it is
classic Nirvana: Balls out, caution to wind, heart on the sleeve, and amazing.
|
|
|